Home » blog » Why Didn’t They Ask Evans (2022) Review: A Comic Mystery Romance to Love

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans (2022) Review: A Comic Mystery Romance to Love

Hugh Laurie adapted the new Agatha Christie adaptation – now available to watch on Britbox.

A comic mystery romance, the latest Britbox original, Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? is unabashedly romantic and old-fashioned in the most entertaining of ways.

Why didn't they ask evans 2022 review: picture of promotional poster

An adaptation of a 1934 Agatha Christie novel, Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? (2022) is refreshingly light, unlike other recent dark Christie interpretations (Death of the Nile comes to mind). 

RELATED: Murder on the Orient Express (2017) – A Glamorous Agatha Christie Period Drama

With an intriguing mystery, witty banter between our leads, and fun direction from Hugh Laurie (House)Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? is a period drama delight.

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans – 2022 Trailer

When you watch the trailer, you can see a taste of why I absolutely loved this limited romantic mystery series!

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans Britbox Synopsis: 

Lucy Boynton as Frankie Derwent and Will Poulter as Bobby Jones in Why Didn't They Ask Evans 2022.
Lucy Boynton as Frankie Derwent and Will Poulter as Bobby Jones. Credit: Britbox

Agatha Christie’s wittiest mystery ever. Lucy Boynton and Will Poulter star in Hugh Laurie’s new adaptation, where two amateur sleuths set out to find the meaning behind a dead man’s mysterious final words.

You can watch the mystery series on Britbox by clicking here.

The Story

While searching for a lost golf ball on a golf course, Bobby Jones (son of the local vicar in a small Welsh town) accidentally stumbles onto a dying man at the bottom of a cliff, a man with enough of a final breath to ask, “why didn’t they ask Evans?” 

It’s the cryptic question of the hour, a question of no seeming importance until Bobby Jones’s life is in danger based on what he witnessed – especially after finding a mysterious photograph of a beautiful young woman inside the dead man’s pocket. 

Will Poulter as Bobby Jones.
Will Poulter as Bobby Jones. Credit: Britbox

Indeed, mysterious and suspicious individuals start showing up around town asking questions, and no one is safe. Not Bobby or Lady Frankie Derwent.

RELATED: 35 Amazing Romantic British Mystery Series to Watch

From there, the story follows the young man, Bobby, and his vivacious companion, the socialite and pants-wearing Lady Frances, otherwise known as Frankie, as they attempt to solve the murder together, a murder that puts these sleuths in the middle of an adventure, mortal danger, and a conspiracy where they don’t know who to trust but each other. 

Lucy Boynton as Frankie Derwent.
Lucy Boynton as Frankie Derwent. Credit: Britbox

Thankfully, Frankie (aka socialite Lady Frances) strives for danger and excitement! But will the two amateur detectives find the murderer before it’s too late?

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans TV Cast (2022)

Will Poulter and Lucy Boynton take on the lead roles as the appropriately named Bobby Jones and the clever Lady Frances Derwent.

RELATED: MASTERPIECE Mystery 2022 Schedule: 7 New and Returning Mysteries to Watch on PBS

Hugh Laurie as Dr. Nicholson in Why Didn't They Ask Evans 2022.
Hugh Laurie as Dr. Nicholson. Credit: Britbox

Other supporting (but significant) players include director Hugh Laurie as Dr. James Nicholson; Jonathan Jules as Ralph “Knocker” Beadon; Conleth Hill as Dr. Alwyn Thomas; Maeve Dermody as Moira Nicholson; Daniel Ings as Roger Bassington-ffrench; Miles Jupp as Henry Bassington-ffrench; Amy Nuttall (Downton Abbey) as Sylvia Bassington-ffrench; Jim Broadbent as Lord Marcham; Emma Thompson as Lady Marcham; Alistair Petrie as Reverend Richard Jones; Paul Whitehouse as Askew; Morwenna Banks as Amelia Cayman; and many more!

The Romance

Lucy Boynton and Will Poulter in Why Didn’t They Ask Evans?
Lucy Boynton and Will Poulter in Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? Credit: Britbox

Unlike other Agatha Christie stories, romance is at the forefront of the series. Indeed, the entire premise of the Why Didn’t They Ask Evans adaptation is about the sparks between Frankie and Bobby. 

In fact, Hugh Laurie focuses his direction almost like a 1930s classic screwball comedy starring Katherine Hepburn and Cary Grant. While the murder and mystery are essential, it’s the relationship and witty repartee between the leads we stay for.

Indeed, the chemistry between Lucy Boynton (Frankie) and Will Poulter (Bobby) is fabulous. Lucy Boynton (who also played a young Margaret in Sense and Sensibility) is a particular standout here.

Boynton plays Frankie with intelligent flirtiness and wit. She’s likable, and you’ll want to root for her happy ending with her childhood friend, Bobby.

RELATED: Miss Scarlet and the Duke Season 2: Everything We Know So Far

For Frankie, it’s of no importance that Bobby isn’t from the same high society as she is, although there is a slight hesitancy because of the class difference. Bobby just needs to realize Frankie is 100 percent ready for a real relationship. 

She’s even willing to put herself in danger by going undercover amid a suspicious family for him! 

While the mystery never takes a backseat, the romance between Bobby and Frankie is as captivating as the rest of this fun adaptation. 

Not to mention, the series stays refreshingly true to the book (unlike the strange Miss Marple version of the story).

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans Review: Our Overall Thoughts

With wit, romance, a juicy mystery, a beautiful setting, and genuinely likable plucky sleuths, Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? is a rollicking good whodunnit. 

While the press for this underrated mystery show went under the radar, it is still well worth checking out.

Emma Thompson as Lady Marcham in Why Didn't They Ask Evans
Emma Thompson as Lady Marcham. Credit: Britbox

Plus, while the leads are great, there are other fantastic cameos in the series, including big names like the always-amazing Emma Thompson and Jim Broadbent. 

Not to mention, Hugh Laurie plays an important onscreen role as well. 

Overall, take an Agatha Christie (the queen of crime) murder mystery, mix in some 1930s screwball romantic comedy elements with a touch of Jane Austen, add a delightfully witty script, and you have Laurie’s lighthearted mystery series, Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? It’s an enjoyable crime-solving adventure with the perfect dose of romance on the side.

In short, if you love romantic mysteries, you’ll love investigating with Frankie and Bobby as they slowly unravel the mystery of why didn’t they ask Evans? 

It truly is a delight; one can only hope Laurie directs more period drama mysteries.

Content Note: TV-MA for brief strong language and brief violence. Overall, the three-part series is very mild, and TV-14 is a more fitting rating.

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? 2022: Where To Watch

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? is exclusively available to stream on Britbox or the Britbox Amazon Channel. There are about three hour-long episodes.

Did you watch Why Didn’t They Ask Evans? What did you think of the latest Agatha Christie adaptation? Let me know in the comments!

You can read more of our reviews here (including other TV shows).

Five corsets rating
Five Vintage Hearts Rating

Why Didn’t They Ask Evans (2022) Review: A Comic Mystery Romance to Love; pinterest image


By on July 13th, 2022

About Autumn Topping

In second grade, Autumn wrote her first story, “The Spinach Monster,” and hasn't stopped writing since. Intrigued by the tales her grandmother told of vampires, witches, and ghosts as a girl, she's always been drawn to the fantastic. Later, Autumn studied English and Creative Writing (continuing her love for classic literature and everything old-fashioned) and graduated with an MA in Children’s Literature and an MS in Library & Information Science from Simmons College. Currently, she co-runs this lovely site and works as a YA Librarian.

More posts by this author.

2 thoughts on “Why Didn’t They Ask Evans (2022) Review: A Comic Mystery Romance to Love”

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.