Home » blog » Typing Fictional Characters: Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries

Typing Fictional Characters: Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries

The cast of Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries. Photo: Acorn
The cast of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries.
Photo: Acorn

Recently I discovered the Australian gem Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries and binge watched the series until I was completely caught up. If you’re not familiar with this lesser known series (a costume drama I actually like more than Downton Abbey – which is hard to do) about a lady detective in 1920’s Australia, then you should definitely check it out.

Detective Jack Robinson (Nathan Page) and Miss Phryne Fisher (Essie Davis). Photo: Acorn
Detective Jack Robinson (Nathan Page) and Miss Phryne Fisher (Essie Davis).
Photo: Acorn

In America, the first season is on Netflix. There’s wit, romance, mystery and murder. It’s an absolutely fantastic show with stunning costumes, set designs and of course unforgettable characters. And since this is a feature about typing fictional characters, it’s the characters I’d like to focus on.

Again, if you’d like a summary of the different Myers Briggs personality types, make sure to read my previous two posts here and here. And per usual, if you’d like the description of the 16 different types you can read them from the Myers Briggs Foundation.

To take the official professional test, go to www.mbtionline.com.

As for the show, there are quite a few characters on Miss Fisher, both recurring and regular, so I figured I’d give them all a try. There’s a couple I was on the fence about (IE: Jane), so I may come back and change my mind.  But for now, here are the Myers Briggs Personality Types of the characters from Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries:

Miss Phryne Fisher: ENTP – The Visionary

Miss Fisher

A lover of intellectual debate, Miss Fisher is always looking for a good sparring partner, which she happily finds with Detective Jack Robinson. Using her logic and wit (as well as her extraverted intuition) she’s able to solve just about any mystery that comes her way. She is spontaneous, fun loving, and caring, but she does have a low tolerance for boredom. Her radical perspectives as a woman in the 1920s make her a true visionary for change.

 Detective Jack Robinson: INTJ – The Scientist

Jack 2

Jack Robinson is the ultimate independent thinker with a love for intellectual banter and debate. He uses logic as well as his introverted intuition to solve cases and often likes to do it on his own. That is until Miss Fisher gets in the way. At first he finds her to be a little bit of a nuisance, but their sparring and equal level of intellect draws him in. With Miss Fisher, he’s found his match. Together they make the perfect crime solving team.

Dorothy “Dot” Williams: ISFJ – The Nurturer

Dot 2

Dot is the loyal companion of Miss Fisher with deeply held Catholic values (even though to the horror of her priest she falls in love with a Protestant). She’s friendly, smart and dependable. She may be much more behind the scenes (and more than a little shy) than Miss Fisher, but with her keen observation skills she helps Miss Fisher solve many of the cases. No matter what, you can always count on Dot to do the right thing.

Constable Hugh Collins: ISTJ – The Duty Fulfiller


With Constable Hugh, it’s all about right and wrong (even though he doesn’t particularly like to break rules). Like Dot, he always tries to do the right thing which makes them a good match despite both of them being incredibly shy. He’s loyal to his friends above all else, and nothing is more important than his duty as a constable and to the ones he loves. He’s private and doesn’t like emotional conflict, but he’s very sweet, thoughtful and extremely dependable.

Aunt Prudence: ESTJ – The Guardian

Aunt Prudence

Miss Fisher’s Aunt Prudence is a traditionalist by nature and doesn’t always understand the radical behavior of her niece.  She loves to organize, plan and take charge of every situation with an iron fist. She’s direct, efficient and plans events better than anyone. She may be extremely society conscious but she does care about people, she’s just practical about it.

Bert: ESTP – The Doer


Bert is the fun loving Communist who may appear a little tough on the outside, but is quite caring on the inside. He’s direct, savors adventure and doesn’t mind conflict one bit. He loves to jump right in to a problem and get things done; and he’s not afraid to go outside of the law to do it, especially when Miss Fisher needs his help. He relies on his best friend Cec, who has more of a bleeding heart than he does, but they make a good pair.

Cec: ISFJ – The Nurturer

Cec and Burt

Cec is one half of the taxi driving duo (his best friend Bert the other half). He’s very loyal, and while he does break the law for the greater good, he follows his heart. Using his introverted sensing, Cec has a photographic memory and keen observational skills which always comes in handy (especially when Miss Fisher is on the case). He’s amiable, sweet and dependable and has a soft spot for anyone in trouble, especially stray dogs and distressed women.

Dr. Mac: ENTJ – The Executive

Dr Mac

Dr. Mac is the best friend of Miss Fisher and is there for her no matter what. Like Phryne, she mocks social conventions and wants social change (even if it’s not happening as quickly as she would like). She’s extremely direct to a fault and a natural leader who loves a good debate. Conflict doesn’t bother her in the slightest, so she has no qualms in telling everyone exactly what she thinks, which can get her into trouble sometimes. She relishes new experiences, taking everything head on, and doesn’t care what anyone thinks.

Mr. Butler: INFJ – The Protector

Mr. Butler and Dot

Mr. Butler comes to work for Miss Fisher thinking she is a quiet spinster. He learns how wrong he was and adjusts quickly. With the use of his introverted intuition, he’s able to anticipate Phryne’s every need (or anyone else’s for that matter) with an almost sixth sense. He always knows exactly what to say and gives great advice. He sees the truth of situations before everyone else does and quietly shares his views when everyone is ready. He’s gentle and may work behind the scenes making sure everything and everyone is harmonious, but he’s not afraid of a good fight either.

Jane: ISFP – The Artist


Jane is a girl Phryne saves off the streets. She is very private and keeps many thoughts and secrets to herself. It takes Phryne a lot of patience to get Jane to talk, let alone to trust her, but once she does they become very attached to each other. Jane doesn’t like traditional education and often gets in trouble at school, but she’s extremely clever, both street smart as well as book smart (having taught herself to read). It may take a little while to get to know her since she keeps her feelings to herself, but she’s very caring and wants everyone to get along.

Agree? Disagree? How would you type the characters of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries? Let me know in the comments!

Photo Credit: ABC/Acorn



I attempt to type fictional characters using the Myers Briggs Assessment. I base my choices on research and all around educated guessing (being the amateur I am). It’s all in good fun and I love a good discussion, so if you agree or disagree with my choices let me know!



Check out my post Myers Briggs and Typing Fictional Characters

Don’t miss the personality typing for the characters from Chuck here 

Read the TV Review: Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries Series One

Check out the Top 30 TV Couples of 2013 (including Miss Fisher and Jack)

Silver Petticoat Review Logo Our romance-themed entertainment site is on a mission to help you find the best period dramas, romance movies, TV shows, and books. Other topics include Jane Austen, Classic Hollywood, TV Couples, Fairy Tales, Romantic Living, Romanticism, and more. We’re damsels not in distress fighting for the all-new optimistic Romantic Revolution. Join us and subscribe. For more information, see our About, Old-Fashioned Romance 101, Modern Romanticism 101, and Romantic Living 101.
Pin this article to read later! And make sure to follow us on Pinterest.



By on January 14th, 2014

About Amber Topping

Amber works as a writer and digital publisher full-time and fell in love with stories and imagination at an early age. She has a Humanities and Film Degree from BYU, co-created The Silver Petticoat Review, contributed as a writer to various magazines, and has an MS in Publishing from Pace University, where she received the Publishing Award of Excellence and wrote her thesis on transmedia, Jane Austen, and the romance genre. Her ultimate dreams are publishing books, writing and producing movies, traveling around the world, and forming a creative village of talented storytellers trying to change the world through art.

More posts by this author.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.