Home » blog » Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Review – The Most Romantic Star Wars Film Since ‘The Empire Strikes Back’

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Review – The Most Romantic Star Wars Film Since ‘The Empire Strikes Back’

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story ReviewRogue One

Rogue One captures what The Force Awakens failed to do: the spirit of the original Star Wars films. (Sorry but emo Kylo Ren as the offspring of Han and Leia just did not do it for me.) More than that, however, Rogue One, tells another epic space opera story with memorable characters that make the original films feel even more complete.

Set not too long before “A New Hope” begins, Rogue One answers how the Death Star plans were stolen. It is these death plans (in Princess Leia’s hands) that lead the way to victory at the end of “A New Hope.” For fans who ever wondered how these plans were attained in the battle mentioned in “A New Hope” prologue, this is the Star Wars film for you!

When just a girl, Jyn Erso’s mother gets killed by leaders from the Empire. Her engineer father (Mads Mikkelsen) then gets taken to work on a superweapon known as the Death Star. This terrible weapon can destroy planets with just one blast.

Rogue One
Mads Mikkelsen

Years later, Jyn (played by the talented Felicity Jones – who I can’t help but always think in connection to Northanger Abbey) was rescued and raised by a resistance leader named Gerrera (Forest Whitaker’s odd performance probably the weakest aspect of the film). Later abandoned as a teenager, Jyn is once more on her own. Stuck in prison, the Rebel Alliance breaks her out. Reports surfaced of an Empire pilot gone rogue with some important intel from her father. And because of her connections to both her father and Gerrera, the Rebel Alliance needs her help!

RELATED | Classic Romantic Moment: Northanger Abbey’s Mr. Tilney and Catherine Banter At A Ball

Rogue One

Unfortunately, Jyn has no interest in politics and only helps them reluctantly in exchange for her freedom. Then she joins forces with a resistance fighter named Cassian (played by Diego Luna who I absolutely adore in this role) and everything changes. Cassian has done everything for the Resistance. He has even made morally gray choices in the name of the rebellion against the Empire. He’s a killer that follows orders, but can he overcome that in order to attain redemption and fight against the Empire at the same time?

After finally meeting up with Gerrera, Jyn watches a hologram of her father. In charge of the development of the Death Star’s weapon, he implanted himself amongst the Empire so he could destroy if from within. In order to do so, he designed a flaw, a flaw, the rebels would later use to destroy the Deathstar in “A New Hope.” But first, the plans need to be stolen.

Rogue One
The Team of “Rogue One”

With a newfound hope and desire to fulfill her father’s wishes, Jyn and Cassian become unlikely allies with the help of a rude, mistrusting enforcer droid named K-2SO (voiced by Firefly‘s Alan Tudyk). They also join forces with the blind, but faithful believer of the force, Chirrut Îmwe. Then there is the fierce fighter Baze Malbus and redemptive New Republic pilot, Bodhi Rook. Together, they name themselves Rogue One, a perfect name for the rebels of the Rebel Alliance. Their plan? Infiltrate the headquarters on the planet Scarif in order to obtain the Death Star blueprints.

Their task is one of sacrifice and hope, with the knowledge they have very little chance in succeeding. The battle begins and our heroes attempt the impossible but can they succeed with everything stacked against them?

Rogue One
Chirrut Imwe uses the Force to fight stormtroopers.

What transpires is both exciting and emotional. More than any of the films since Return of the Jedi, Rogue One takes the Force and makes it believable once again. I could feel the spiritual power of the Force in the film right down to the goosebumps on my arms, the Force no longer a caricature of its former self. The film surprisingly achieves this without a Jedi to lead the way, but rather through the believers of a dying religion. The faith of the blind Chirrut Îmwe who uses his faith in the Force “to see” is both powerful and beautiful to witness onscreen.

Rogue One

No longer a shadow of his former self, Darth Vader also makers a powerful comeback. In his brief appearances, Darth Vader is ferocious and truly villainous. One fight sequence was particularly exciting and chilling.

What truly sets Rogue One apart from other films, however, is the focus on the characters rather than on action. While the action scenes are still amazing, I appreciated the quieter moments. Jyn and Cassian particularly stand out as they feel like fleshed out real characters rather than the cardboard cutouts given to us in The Force Awakens. Sorry, but the main three characters were dullsville central… Felicity Jones plays Jyn as a flawed female heroine who grows into a leader with ease while Diego Luna captures the dark but good spirit in Cassian with an intense charisma that kept me glued to the screen. The two actors also had quite the believable chemistry.

Felicity Jones have amazing romantic chemistry and I'm not backing down from that...
Felicity Jones and Diego Luna have amazing romantic chemistry as Jyn and Cassian and I’m not backing down from that…

Mild Spoilers

And while some are cheering on the “feminist” lack of romance (Teen Vogue I am looking at you), they missed the entire point of the film. First of all, it is absolutely ridiculous to call a film feministic simply because of a supposed lack of romance – which was actually one of the main aspects of the film. Perhaps many viewers can no longer recognize subtext? If people aren’t kissing or sleeping together or literally confessing their feelings aloud, then there must be no romance, correct? Wrong. Still, there is nothing wrong with romance. It’s when women are objectified or simply turned into “the girlfriend” role that is the problem.

That all said Rogue One can’t be “A New Hope” or “Return of the Jedi” where romantic happy endings are possible. As Cassian points out through subtext, they don’t have the luxury to get close, to live normal lives. Rather, these characters are the ones who must sacrifice to offer hope to those who come after them. Without the fighters of Rogue One, Princess Leia and Han Solo would never have met. On a side note, I’m still seething from “The Force Awakens” breakup!!

Indeed, the entire movie Rogue One has subtext and old-fashioned romantic elements sprinkled throughout. It is about what isn’t said because they can’t say it rather than literal proclamations of love. (Which, by the way, wouldn’t have fit the film at all.) Looks, conversations with double meanings, and the romantic ending pretty much says it all in my book. And as a huge lover of old-fashioned and intelligent romance over cheesy scenes of hooking up, I absolutely loved every scene between Jyn and Cassian. How people missed the romantic tension is beyond me…

Aside from the characters and romance, however, the major standout of Rogue One is hands down the visual effects. In order to create believable continuity, the visual effects team used new and advanced technology to bring back one of the now dead stars of “A New Hope:” Peter Cushing. The CGI really made me believe this familiar character came back to life on my screen and I loved it! There are few other surprises in the film as well, but I won’t spoil the fun!

Overall, Rogue One definitely deserves your time. Well written (with actual good dialogue), fantastic acting with a diverse cast, a believable story to set up “A New Hope, and striking visual effects all weave together effortlessly to tell a story from a galaxy far away and long ago. Make sure not to miss this one on the big screen!

Content Note: Rated PG-13 for fantasy/sci-fi violence.

Where to Watch: In theaters. Rogue One will be available on Digital March 24, 2017, and DVD April 4.

What did you think of Rogue One? Sound off below…

Photos: Disney/Lucasfilm Entertainment


Five Corset Rating Lower Byte Size

“The stuff that dreams are made of.”


Five heart rating

“You pierce my soul. I am half agony, half hope.

I have loved none but you.”

Silver Petticoat Review Logo Our romance-themed entertainment site is on a mission to help you find the best period dramas, romance movies, TV shows, and books. Other topics include Jane Austen, Classic Hollywood, TV Couples, Fairy Tales, Romantic Living, Romanticism, and more. We’re damsels not in distress fighting for the all-new optimistic Romantic Revolution. Join us and subscribe. For more information, see our About, Old-Fashioned Romance 101, Modern Romanticism 101, and Romantic Living 101.
Pin this article to read later! And make sure to follow us on Pinterest.


By on January 17th, 2017

About Autumn Topping

In second grade, Autumn wrote her first story, “The Spinach Monster,” and hasn't stopped writing since. Intrigued by the tales her grandmother told of vampires, witches, and ghosts as a girl, she's always been drawn to the fantastic. Later, Autumn studied English and Creative Writing (continuing her love for classic literature and everything old-fashioned) and graduated with an MA in Children’s Literature and an MS in Library & Information Science from Simmons College. Currently, she co-runs this lovely site and works as a YA Librarian.

More posts by this author.

4 thoughts on “Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Review – The Most Romantic Star Wars Film Since ‘The Empire Strikes Back’”

    I liked your review (and your blog btw) it’s a fresh vision of the movie and it’s much more interesting coz you developp on a point not many people talked about.

    I kinda see their relation as a embryon of love relation, because of their lives (they were made to sacrifice their lives (Cassian was a soldier since he was 6 he said, from that what life could he have? he can’t have the luxury to fall in love and live his love story. That’s what I’d like to insist on, my vision of the movie would be that it was actually clear (but hidden) from the beginning of the movie that the group was a sacrifice group (you need to know I didn’t read the synopsis, niether did I watch the trailer when I watched the movie the first time so it was total surprise) : Cassian is the hero but when he present the group of voluntears for the mission Jyn proposed, it’s made quite clear he and the group are all the same : they can’t be a real person they are like simply rebels, they are soldiers and when you know Cassian was a soldier from his 6 it seems clear these rebels didn’t have time to live their lives, and it’s almost the same for Jyn. From that their relation is complicated, they don’t have time for it because first of all they are soldiers before persons.

    So Jyn’s relation with Cassian is (for me) the one of Jyn with a rebel, of a girl soldier with a man soldier -> according the context their relation was destroyed (not impossible but cut) from the beginning, thats what imo is so tragic about them, we see an embryo of relation made impossible by the context and the tragedies of their lives, any of them can be a lover because they were almost born soldiers. Without the context of the war they are nodoby so the movie could only show us their tragedy : even if they had SPOIL SPOIL survived the mission what could they have done? only war.

    So for me its the movie of a sacrified generation, group of people, it is the desaster that A new hope didn’t show us, its A star wars story, the story of the forgotten, the one who like the heros fought, but who aren’t the heros, the work in the shadow. It’s not the story of Jyn and Cassian, but the one of what they mean : these people sacrified by the empire and war and that we don’t know. It’s like the other half of a new hope, it’s when there was no hope.

    That’s why I loved the movie and found it so sad and very tragic. There was no solution for them, from the beginning they were doomed. It’s like the best prequel A new hope could “hope for” (couldn’t help it lol) because you then see all the impact A new hope have what it prevented, the tragedy it has stopped : no more Jyn and Cassian, their death could also mean the end of doomed generations, which is also a sign of hope.

    • You really make some excellent points. I didn’t go too into detail because I didn’t completely want to spoil the ending, but I completely agree with you. The tragedy of the film is what makes it so beautiful and romantic. Their lives only knew war and that was all they were going to ever know. It’s a pity some people can’t recognize the depth behind these characters and script.

  2. Even though I enjoyed The Force Awakens, I completely agree with your assessment of Rogue One. FA definitely suffers from its lack of character development, mainly due to this notion of keeping Rey’s parentage a mystery, while RO gives Jyn and the others many moments to shine. The last scene between Jyn and Cassian is one of the most romantic movie moments I’ve seen in quite a while.

  3. Yes! Finally saw this and am smitten! It’s hand’s down the best installment since the original trilogy. I loved the originals, HATED the prequel trilogy, and haven’t been so impressed with the current sequels, so I’d pretty much given up hope. But this is a total gem. And so much bittersweet romantic restraint, where individual desires are subsumed by the greater good — oh man, now that is ROMANCE!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.