Home » blog » When Calls the Heart Season Three: Hearts in Question Recap – Wedding Shenanigans and Future Mother-In-Laws

When Calls the Heart Season Three: Hearts in Question Recap – Wedding Shenanigans and Future Mother-In-Laws

When Calls the Heart S3 E8: Hearts in Question

When Calls the Heart Season Three, Episode Eight Recap: Hearts in Question

Sunday’s episode of When Calls the Heart, “Hearts in Question,” was, quite surprisingly, a humorous hour of television. After last week’s swoony romantic moment between one of Hope Valley’s couples, this week plays off of that romantic proposal by dealing in some lighthearted stuff. Brooke Shields also guested as a new character whom we’ll talk about later on in this recap.

RELATED | When Calls the Heart, Season Three: Heartbreak Recap – Changes and a Reluctant Bride

A Perfect Wedding (Minus Guests)

When Calls the Heart S3 E8: Hearts in Question

In typical Rosemary fashion, her recent engagement to Lee isn’t something she takes lightly. Instead of a quiet affair, which is all Lee needs, she’s making an event out of it. Naturally, this also means some of her perfectionist visions of the wedding causes some fumbles in the planning. She nitpicks Elizabeth’s kind offer to write out the place cards and makes plans for elaborate bridal gowns all while doubting Abigail’s catering skill.

Eventually, as reply cards begin to pour in, Rosemary learns her wedding may be small after all. Even her best friend refuses to attend on account of her pregnancy, which Rosemary finds ridiculous. After all, she should have planned better! Lee tries to smooth things over with Rosemary, but he does wonder if she persists if they’ll have any friends left to attend the festivities.

Rosemary insisting doves be released on her wedding day! Hearts in Question
Rosemary insisting doves be released on her wedding day!

All of this nonsense reveals a few things about Lee and Rosemary as a couple which does inspire some friction in their relationship. Hopefully not enough to cause any sort of break up, but Rosemary did harbor some doubt. (I don’t mind admitting, this leaves me sad. Despite Rosemary’s trying personality, these two are so cute together.)

For now, “Hearts in Question,” ends on a happy note when Rosemary receives a telegram from her friend. The message tells Rosemary that she now has a namesake; her friend named her newborn daughter after her.

Meeting Jack’s Mother

Meanwhile, in “Hearts in Question,” Jack and Elizabeth’s courtship encounter a new challenge with the arrival of Jack’s mother, Charlotte. Riding into town under the cover of darkness wearing a Stetson and travelling by horse, she shows up unexpectedly at Jack’s door. The following morning when Elizabeth stops by the jail to see Jack, she’s surprised to meet his mother. After some awkward words (and Jack trying to set right his remarks that the women in his life can’t cook), Elizabeth invites Charlotte to stay with her.

When Calls the Heart S3 E8: Hearts in Question

As Elizabeth adjusts to her new roommate, she discovers that she and Charlotte are very different. Charlotte rises early and washes her own clothes (Elizabeth pays someone in the town) like a real pioneer woman, and she seems to think lard is the end all in cooking. But even though they clash, they find common ground in their shared profession of teaching. Both women work together to better the education of the settlement children.

When Calls the Heart S3 E8: Hearts in Question

Jack buys the land he’d been interested in and finally takes Elizabeth to see his recent purchase, asking her what she thinks. Cue the cute flirting!

Elsewhere: Hope Valley Happenings

+ Frank and Abigail put a label on their relationship: they are officially courting. All inspired by Abigail’s recent trip. She and Cody were gone for a brief period of time to see Becky win the scholarship for her project.
+ The ladies of Hope Valley host a bridal shower for Rosemary while Charlotte sits in the saloon with the men beating them all in a game of poker.
+ Jesse is shunned by Clara because he is working for Gowen, who she’s had unpleasant dealings with.
+ Speaking of the mayor, he’s in hot water. The banker warns him there is an audit coming, which spooks Gowen. Running from something, he convinces Nora to leave with him, and as the episode closes, on the slick wet road, their car skids into an embankment.
+ Weakened by the heavy rains drenching Hope Valley’s surrounding areas, the mine where Roy (the young husband Jack just reunited with his family) works is also on the verge of caving in as the episode closes.

Have any thoughts, hopes or theories about the final two episodes? Sound off below.

Photos: Hallmark


Read more of our TV Recaps including our When Calls the Heart season three recaps! Can’t get enough of When Calls the Heart? Browse our archives for more articles or reviews on this show or read our Romantic Moment of the Week feature Jack and Elizabeth.

Silver Petticoat Review Logo Our romance-themed entertainment site is on a mission to help you find the best period dramas, romance movies, TV shows, and books. Other topics include Jane Austen, Classic Hollywood, TV Couples, Fairy Tales, Romantic Living, Romanticism, and more. We’re damsels not in distress fighting for the all-new optimistic Romantic Revolution. Join us and subscribe. For more information, see our About, Old-Fashioned Romance 101, Modern Romanticism 101, and Romantic Living 101.
Pin this article to read later! And make sure to follow us on Pinterest.


By on April 4th, 2016

About Rissi JC

Rissi is a self-diagnosed Bookaholic and TV fandom addict. She’s currently an avid blogger and reader who enjoys interacting with readers, and often dreams about finishing her first novel. When not writing or reading, she can be found working as an INSPYs advisory board member or contributing to e-zines. Her scribbles are housed on her blog Finding Wonderland (https://www.rissiwrites.com).

More posts by this author.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.