13. Impossible Saints by Clarissa Harwood

Set in the 1900s, many reader friends have nothing but glowing things to report about this novel. It’s described as a “novel that burns as brightly as the suffrage movement it depicts.”

Impossible Saints on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

14. A Noble Groom by Jody Hedlund

A Noble Groom Book Cover

Anything by Jody is well written and is a memorable experience. This one features a swoony hero and a kiss that epic romances are made of.  

A Noble Groom on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

15. Engraved on the Heart by Tara Johnson

engraved on the heart book cover; christian historical romance fiction

A debut novel, this Civil War-era novel is an impressive and well-written story. It’s ideal for anyone who enjoys the era, or the period drama Mercy Street.

Engraved on the Heart on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

16. The Mail Order Bride Series by Al and Joanna Lacy

An oldie series that’s more of a western series; what they have in common is they all feature a mail-order bride trope.

The Mail Order Bride Series on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

17. Love at Any Cost by Julie Lessman

A Texas oil heiress clashes with a “handsome pauper” hoping to marry well.

Note: Julie’s novels do tend to be on the more adult side of Christian fiction with some innuendo/adult themes.

Love At Any Cost on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

18. The Matrimonial Advertisement by Mimi Matthews

the matrimonial advertisement book cover

Praised for her prose and novels, this novel marks book one in her Parish Orphans of Devon trilogy. It also has an impressive 4 ½ star rating and 200+ reviews! This one is about a marriage of convenience, and though it does have the “clean” tag, just be aware, there are some minor expletives.

The Matrimonial Advertisement on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

19. Love’s Pursuit by Siri Mitchell

Historical fiction set in a Puritan settlement, this one uses the love triangle trope to tell its story.

Love’s Pursuit on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

20. Love Comes Softly by Janette Oke

If you want to read something that’s really sweet, and goes way back into the Christian Fiction archives, there’s none better than Love Comes Softly; and this year it celebrates its 40th anniversary!

Love Comes Softly on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

21. Lady Jayne Disappears by Joanna Davidson Politano

Lady Jane Disappears book cover; christian historical romance novels

This one is a 1800s mystery you’re sure to enjoy if you like period dramas like Mystery of a Hansom Cab or The Moonstone.

Lady Jayne Disappears on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

22. Through Waters Deep by Sarah Sundin

When it comes to WWII fiction, you really cannot go wrong with anything by Sarah Sundin. But one of my favorites by her is Through Waters Deep, a cozy mystery that reminds so many readers of Nancy Drew! Most importantly, it’s romantic, too.

Through Waters Deep on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

23. A Change of Fortune by Jen Turano

If stories with a bit of humor are more your thing, then know that Turano’s books always have a nice sense of humor, and also tend to feature spunky heroines!

A Change of Fortune on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

24. The Number of Love by Roseanna M. White

Titled as The Codebreakers, this series follows a group of people who work to break codes in “Room 40” during the Great War.

The Number of Love on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

25. Marrying Miss Marshal by Lacy Williams

This is a reprint novel and seems to be a western about a fierce lady marshal who’s determined to keep order in her small town. Sounds fun, right?

Marrying Miss Marshal on Amazon | Add on Goodreads

In addition to these 25 titles, there are countless other Christian historical romance novels written by many other authors! Just a few of these include Karen Barrett, Ann H. Gabhart, Elizabeth Ludwig, Lorna Seilstad, Mary Lu Tyndall, Karen Whitemeyer, and so many more!

To sum up this list, I’m curious about your favorites. Tell me, which of these have you read? Do you have any must-read Christian (or inspirational) historical fiction favorites? I’d love to know about your favorite Christian historical romance novels! Sound off below with all of your thoughts.

Silver Petticoat Review Logo Our romance-themed entertainment site is on a mission to help you find the best period dramas, romance movies, TV shows, and books. Other topics include Jane Austen, Classic Hollywood, TV Couples, Fairy Tales, Romantic Living, Romanticism, and more. We’re damsels not in distress fighting for the all-new optimistic Romantic Revolution. Join us and subscribe. For more information, see our About, Old-Fashioned Romance 101, and Modern Romanticism 101.
If you enjoyed this article, please help us spread the word! Share with your friends or save to Pinterest to read later.


You May Also Like: