Select Page

Brooklyn Movie Review: A Beautiful, Heartwarming Film

Brooklyn Movie Review: A Beautiful, Heartwarming Film

brooklyn 2

Brooklyn (2015) is a film about an Irish immigrant in the 1950s and the choices she must make in life and also, therefore, love. Directed by John Crowley, starring Saoirse Ronan, Domhall Gleeson, and Emory Cohen, it’s a beautiful watch and my favorite movie of the year. Here’s why!

How to Immediately Fall In Love With Brooklyn 

  1. Watch the trailer for this film and immediately sob and replay this beautiful 2-minute video whirlwind of romance, scenery, adventure, family conflict and Irish ballad music six times. Then send to all of your friends and parents.
  2. Go to see the movie on your next day off and find yourself surrounded by exclusively adorable elderly couples. Admire how many heads of silver hair provide great lighting in theaters when finding your seats in the dark. Bite back the urge to ask all the couples if they, too, immigrated from Ireland in the 1950s, because that is totally inappropriate, EVEN IF THEY MAYBE DID!
  3. Get swept up by beautiful film-making and a film that touches the heart.
  4. Stare at many pictures of Emory Cohen since finding a 1950s Italian fella might not be possible anymore in 2015.
  5. Fall hard for the charm of a simple film about ordinary struggles within family and love and remember to interview your grandparents extensively about their love stories when you get home.
  6. Realize that Saoirse Ronan is just the best and you can forgive her for all her character did in Atonement! 

Brooklyn has the feel of a classic film because it has all the elements that warm your heart. Saoirse Ronan plays a young woman from Ireland who immigrates to Brooklyn in the 1950s, leaving behind her mother and sister in search of a better life. She lives in a boarding house and works in a fancy department store, bitterly lonely until she adjusts to life in Brooklyn.

brooklyn - Saoirse Ronan

Saoirse Ronan acted so perfectly in this role.

After a while, she starts to like living in Brooklyn as she begins attending class at Brooklyn College and dating an “Italian fella” named Tony Fiorello. (Somehow, this is now a super attractive name to me. Like, I really wish I could date a Tony Fiorello now.)

Brooklyn -Emory Cohen

I stared at Emory Cohen and his beautiful cute face with equal looks of wonder during the film.

It’s the 1950s, and for some reason because of that I feel like saying “dating is in full swing!” but what I really mean is that in movies people seemed to go to swing dances and date. Which is what Tony and Eilis do, and they fall in love. This was such a wonderful part of the film…it’s simple, it’s sweet, it will just make you so happy to watch. He’s not a questionable guy with a bad past, he’s just an honest plumber living with his family. They’re from different cultures, but in the time of immigration it seems less conflictual to marry outside one’s culture because you’re in the melting pot and you have to assimilate. Or…is it even more conflictual because all you can do as an immigrant is hold on more tightly to your own culture?

brooklyn - Tony and Eilis

Tony and Eilis at, presumably, a swing dance.

This question of where your heart and loyalty lies is explored when a family emergency sends Eilis back to Ireland, where she grows comfortable, back at home. Oh, home, that whisper of a word you can never hide from. It always finds you. So many movies and books have the theme of returning to your roots, but for immigrants this conflict – between home and a new life – is inexpressibly difficult. It was heart-wrenching to try to imagine how Eilis, and so many others, must have felt coming to America. Eilis does not just have to decide between an Irish and an Italian man, she has to decide between home and her new life in Brooklyn. I think of rom-coms where the character vainly struggles to follow their dreams as a writer instead of a teacher and those struggles seem silly in light of this character struggling to decide between following her heart when it means traveling so far and sacrificing everything she’s ever known.

brooklyn - Saoirse Ronan and Domhall Gleeson

Saoirse Ronan and Domhall Gleeson in a scene in Ireland. (Ugh…think of the beautiful redhead children that could be!)

To make this film exceptional, the acting and cast were superb, featuring Julie Watson from Harry Potter, Jim Broadbent, and even Felicity from Arrow! Emory Cohen was made to play adorable 1950s Italian men and Domhall Gleeson was striking as his tall, suitable, kind Irish counterpart. The ladies from the boarding house provided a sort of community for Eilis and provided some pleasant humor. Saoirse Ronan was dizzyingly good, and I really recommend this movie for all to see. No part of it was boring – in fact, Eilis’s story, from start to finish, was engaging and compelling. It’s parts humorous and parts quietly sad to see her leave on her own, a naive, lonely girl and become a confident woman taking her place in Brooklyn as the film goes on.

Brooklyn - Boarding House

The girls from the boardinghouse teaching Eilis to eat Italian food. (Check out Emily Bett Rickards on the right from Arrow!)

The story is both gripping and touching while honestly, completely ordinary. But it’s always the regular things in life that make for the most touching, real tales and Brooklyn capitalized on that. I mean, how many people have had to leave beloved family behind and cried about it daily? Millions! Billions! But even though immigration is the backbone and the basis of this country, the movie made me stop and wonder just how hard it is to do.

I imagine that if I were an Irish immigrant (or an immigrant at all) I would have cried many tears at this lovely film, for it isn’t a gritty historical drama on the struggles of immigrants, but a smooth, lovely film that pulls at your heartstrings while touching on those many conflicts. Many, I think, would identify with the fears of being alone in a new country for the first time, the wonders of first love, and the feeling of family tugging you back home. Do you go for the first-love passionate romance that comes with sacrifice or a comfortable, ideal one surrounded by things that make you happy and a person who could as well? I used to always answer, obviously the former, but family and home carry a strong weight. (I mean, we’ve all seen Sweet Home Alabama.) Eilis’ love triangle is incredibly stressful but very good, which was surprising to even me since I had already picked a favorite.


A blurry Coca-Cola sign, cat-eye sunglasses, a bouncy skirt, a fella and Coney Island are the recipe for a great 1950s period drama! And those baggy brown slacks. I genuinely wish they were back in fashion. They were hotter than all of Christian Grey’s suits combined.

Brooklyn made me go home and play only 1950s hits and again wish that I could somehow visit that time period. It’s a film that made me want to use the words “exquisite” and “marvelous” in this review – I want more movies like this! During the film my sister and I emotionally clutched each other’s hands (particularly at close-ups of Emory Cohen’s face) and made slight sobbing noises at Eilis’s tough decisions and overall felt like our hearts were warm. Because that that was how the film was. Heartwarming.


One last romantic shot!

Brooklyn is based on the novel of the same name by Colm Toibin. 

RATING: Brooklyn is PG-13 but the content is mainly PG, save for one sex scene.

*I tried to watch this movie twice, but the second time it was on a Saturday night in NYC and for some reason every New Yorker in the world was out seeing it because all 3 theaters I went to were sold out (who could have foreseen such?)! Alas, I had to settle for Crimson Peak instead. Which was a good period drama, but Brooklyn was better (sorry Tom Hiddleston!).

Photos: Fox Searchlight Pictures


"The stuff that dreams are made off."

“The stuff that dreams are made of.”


"You pierce my soul. I am half agony, half hope. I have loved none but you.”

“You pierce my soul. I am half agony, half hope.

I have loved none but you.”

About The Author

Amirah Yasin

Amirah Yasin is a lover of persimmons, angst-ridden characters, YA fiction (and all books), Shah Rukh Khan and Colin Firth. In addition to spending her time frequenting YouTube to watch Bollywood songs, attempting to find chances to wear prairie-length skirts, and watching period dramas, she likes to travel, run, play cards and DJ old Indian music. She is a registered nurse as well as an obnoxious snapchat fiend. She enjoys writing idiotic poetry, befriending librarians, and taking photographs of trees. Her elderly patients are the only people known to be fond of her singing voice. She has always loved reading, writing, and romance.

1 Comment

  1. Rissi

    This looks and sounds gorgeous! Thanks so much for sharing your great review, Amirah. If this one doesn’t open near me, I’ll for sure be snagging a copy on DVD. 🙂


Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Welcome to The Silver Petticoat Review, the kindred spirit destination for lovers of romance and Romanticism. We cover both modern and classic film, literature, & TV from around the world and specialize in Old-Fashioned Romance, Period Dramas, Classics, Romanticism, and Modern Romanticism without the excess of explicit content and unsentimental cynicism.




The Silver Petticoat Review is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.



The Silver Petticoat Review

Love Period Dramas & Old-Fashioned Romance? Follow:






Join us as we connect you with the best of romance, period dramas, & Romanticism from around the world. Subscribe for exclusive access to a quarterly newsletter and once a week updates.


Thank you for subscribing!