Home » blog » Classic Romantic Moment Series: Max, Liz and Christmas

Classic Romantic Moment Series: Max, Liz and Christmas

Classic Romantic Moment Series

THE SHOW: Roswell

THE PAIRING: Max (Jason Behr) and Liz (Shiri Appleby)

THE EPISODE: “A Roswell Christmas Carol” (aired December 18, 2000)

THE CLASSIC MOMENT: Max shows up at the Christmas service to tell Liz he believes in her.

Liz and Max celebrating Christmas together in "A Roswell Christmas Carol."
Liz and Max celebrating Christmas together in “A Roswell Christmas Carol.”

Since it’s the holiday season I thought this week I’d turn to the past for a Christmassy romantic moment. That said picking just one is not an easy task as there are so many great Christmas films (It’s a Wonderful Life for instance) and TV specials with memorable romantic moments. From the entire movie of Love Actually, to the proposal in While You Were Sleeping at the train station, Edward Scissorhands carving snow for Kim, Cameron Diaz learning how to cry in The Holiday because she falls in love with Jude Law, to even the Doctor and Rose in The Christmas Invasion as they start to fall in love all over again.

But there’s one moment that is particularly nostalgic to me. And that’s the end scene from Roswell’s second season episode “A Roswell Christmas Carol.” Roswell was my favorite show for the few short seasons it was on and I looked forward to every episode about the Romeo and Juliet story between Max and Liz. Star-crossed love between an alien and a human girl with fantastic writers running the show such as Jason Katims (Friday Night Lights, Parenthood) and Ronald D. Moore (Battlestar Galactica) you just couldn’t go wrong. It’s rumored that at that time, the pilot was the highest testing episode 20th Century Fox had done up to that point so it’s surprising they didn’t actually pick it up. The show eventually found its home at the WB and while it didn’t have huge ratings, the series gathered a large cult following (with the fans helping get a second season for the series by sending Tabasco sauce to the network).

Max and Liz final

All these years later, the show still stands the test of time with “A Roswell Christmas Carol” as one of the best episodes. Its Christmas time and Max, who has the ability to heal others, witnesses a father die saving his daughter. With all of the witnesses present Max chooses to not heal the father so as not to expose his secret. Soon, he finds himself haunted by the father who blames him for not healing him.

Max and the ghost final

Eventually, to make up for it, Max and Michael travel all the way to Phoenix to heal the daughter of a friend who has cancer.

Max saving sydney FINAL

Seeing all of the other children dying, Max goes on to save as many of the sick children as possible with his gift. The episode is all about faith, family and of course romantic love.

Toward the end of the episode, Max goes to see Liz as she gets ready for the local church Christmas Service which Max has no intention of attending making him a little bit of our “Scrooge” if you will, despite his heroic adventures to save all the children. And in relation to saving all of these kids, as much as Liz is touched by what he’s done, she gives him a warning.

“As beautiful as that is, Max, you can’t keep doing it. I know it seems like there’s no reason for those kids to have cancer or for a father to get killed saving his child, or for any of it, but maybe there is. Maybe there is someone or something out there that’s planning all of this. And maybe you have to respect it. You’re not God, Max. You’re the one that told me that.”

respect it FINAL maybe there is FINAL

Based on his expression, it’s obvious they don’t completely see eye to eye here, but they love each other and she wants his support.

“Will you come to midnight service?” Liz asks hopeful.

“I’d like to. But I don’t believe in God.”

Liz can’t hide her disappointment, but she does her best to cover up her feelings.

disappointed final

“Merry Christmas, Liz.” Max says before he leaves knowing he’s let her down.

Waiting for him to be gone, Liz returns the sentiment.

“Merry Christmas, Max.”

Merry Christmas Max FINAL

Soon after, Max finds himself walking down the street with the father who’s been haunting him as Max promises to look out for his family. When Max drops the father off at his house, the ghost tells him to “Get outta here.”

“I don’t know where to go.” Max claims.

“It’s Christmas. You should be with your loved ones. That’s where I’ll be. That’s where I’ll always be.”

I will be there for them 2 final

The father then approaches his own doorstep and goes inside to watch over his own family as an angel who have just lost him.

father smiles final Max watches father FINAL

As “Silent Night” plays, Max turns inward clearly thinking about his own loved ones (his parents, his sister, his friends and especially Liz) all getting ready to attend the Christmas Service without him. Yet seeing this man who can’t be with his family physically, Max still doesn’t plan to attend.

Later, at home, Michael (clearly dressed up to go to Midnight Service) comes to see Max.

“You’re going to midnight service?” Max questions in surprise. “You don’t believe in anything.”

Michael FINAL

“Gotta hedge your bets Maxwell. I’ve had my prayers answered twice in the past two days.” Michael then takes Max to give him his Christmas present: Seeing their friend Brody with his daughter celebrating Christmas now free from cancer.”

Brody 2 FINAL Max watching FINAL

But has Max seen enough to change his mind and embrace the Christmas spirit even if he doesn’t believe in God?

The final scene of the episode, which brings me to the romantic moment of the week, is set with everyone at the midnight service. Everyone but Max that is. As “Oh, Come All Ye Faithful” is sung by the church choir, suddenly Max appears from the street walking toward the crowd.

Max walking toward crowd FINAL

First his family sees him, then Liz who he sits next to. She has a huge smile on her face, unable to contain how happy she is to see him there.

Max smiles at family final Max's family FINAL sits next to Liz FINAL

She leans over to him and says “I thought you didn’t believe in God.”

didn't believe in God final

He then takes her hand and holds it in his own. “I believe in you.”

God 2 final believe in you 2 FINAL hand final Liz smiles final

It’s innocent, sweet and perfect. And just when you think the episode is over and there’s nothing better that can be said or done, something happens.

Just as the choir reaches a new crescendo, snow suddenly starts to fall out of the sky like a small Christmas miracle. Max and Liz look up in wonder and she smiles. The camera pans away as we watch the snow fall on the audience and the choir continues to sing.

snow begins to fall FINAL snow 2 final snow 4 FINAL

It’s a beautiful romantic Christmas moment; one that will always be one of my favorites.

What is your favorite romantic holiday moment in a Movie or TV show? Let me know in the comments!

Photo Credit: WB



Check out our other Classic Romantic Moments! We put up a new one to spotlight regularly.

Read Autumn’s list of the Top 50 Memorable Christmas Movies

Silver Petticoat Review Logo Our romance-themed entertainment site is on a mission to help you find the best period dramas, romance movies, TV shows, and books. Other topics include Jane Austen, Classic Hollywood, TV Couples, Fairy Tales, Romantic Living, Romanticism, and more. We’re damsels not in distress fighting for the all-new optimistic Romantic Revolution. Join us and subscribe. For more information, see our About, Old-Fashioned Romance 101, Modern Romanticism 101, and Romantic Living 101.
Pin this article to read later! And make sure to follow us on Pinterest.


By on December 21st, 2013

About Amber Topping

Amber works as a blogger/writer full-time and fell in love with stories and imagination at an early age. She has a Humanities and Film Degree from BYU, co-created The Silver Petticoat Review, contributed as a writer to various magazines, and has an MS in Publishing from Pace University, where she received the Publishing Award of Excellence and wrote her thesis on transmedia, Jane Austen, and the romance genre. Her ultimate dreams are publishing books, writing and producing movies, traveling around the world, and forming a creative village of talented storytellers trying to change the world through art.

More posts by this author.

7 thoughts on “Classic Romantic Moment Series: Max, Liz and Christmas”

  1. Agreed. It is a lovely episode, and a lovely moment. The word “believe” has a lot of meaning when it comes to Max and Liz…. “I Shall Believe” was their wedding song, after all 🙂

  2. I’m so happy that i’ve found a person has the same thought with me. It’s my favorite christmas scene ever too! nice to know you!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.